Sunday, August 5, 2007

You eat pieces of shit for breakfast?

Welcome to my very first post on this blog. I think it's going pretty well so far.


"let's get down to brass tacks on the midwesterner's assumptions about the Yankees...that we simply purchase success. The very thought that we earned the latest dynasty through good decisions and a good farm system along with our money scares you all. That would mean we could beat other teams at their own game...through smart decisions and good player development. AND, we could back that up with deeper pockets. That combination would mean we'd be very tough to beat. So, as soon as someone in this argument admits this is a possibility...that the Yankees could do things by not just simply throwing their money around...the order of the universe would break down. Is this a fair assessment?"

Yes, I think that an important bedrock point of this whole argument so far has been that the Twins and other low-budget teams are better at making careful, well-reasoned decisions in the free agent market and also better at farming their own talent for cheap than the Yankees. The Yankees don't HAVE to make these kinds of decisions, and so even when they choose RIGHT, they still haven't beaten the Twins "at their own game," because they got that right choice through a lot more casting about with golden doubloons. I also think that as long as the Yankees have the budget they do, and they can buy up seasoned veterans and put them on the field, the likelihood that they will be taking their well-bought rookies and giving them a real chance in the majors, the way the Twins are forced to, is basically nil. I await the evidence that will prove me wrong.


The Twins, I'll agree have produced better talent from their farm system over the past few years than the Yankees. So, their stats aren't surprising. Of course, these stats don't mean a whole lot. When the Yanks play the Twins in the regular season and the post season, they seem to pull the games out more often than not.

And thank you for that. Yes, head-to-head, it seems like the Twins are terrified of the Yankees like little boys are terrified of bears. They still won only one less game in the regular season last year, so those stats seem to mean a whole lot somewhere, now don't they?


See again, the Twins and the Yankees have been able to get teams into the playoffs. The Yankees managed 6 pennants and 4 championships out their playoff teams. The Twins not so much with their recent teams. If a team makes the playoffs, is it fair to say they have the capability to win the WS? I'd say probably. Once you get to the playoffs the payroll and all of this $$ talk is largely irrelevant. The team is in position. The Yankees were able to put a special group of players together to win that went beyond simply spending $$. Again, I'll admit that's a part of our success yes. A necessary, but not sufficient condition for success. You still need other pieces to fall into place that money can't buy.

Oh, son, you just totally ignored the numbers, didn't you? The point was not that the Twins accomplished the SAME THING as the Yankees... it was that for A LOT LOT LOT less money, they accomplished CLOSE. In 2006 both the Twins and the Yankees were knocked out in the first round of the playoffs, and the Twins had only one fewer regular season wins than the Yankees. So, one win cost the Yankees $130 million. In 2005 the Yankees lost in the first round and the Twins didn't go. Twelve wins and a playoff bid cost the Yankees $152 million. In 2004, nine wins and one round further in the playoffs was worth $130.4 million. In 2003 eleven wins and the chance to lose the world series was worth $97.2 million. AND, in 2002, the Yankees won 9 more regular season games, but fell out in the first round of the playoffs while the Twins went on to the second, all for $85.5 million dollars less.

You see where I'm going here? Yes, the Yankees have more pennants and more World Series titles, but they are also doing it EXTREMELY inefficiently. I have the suspicion that raising the payroll a few million dollars might help solidify the Twins' playoff bids for the next 5 years, and even make the likelihood of a pennant or even World Series title more likely. But I don't think that they need to spend THREE TIMES AS MUCH. So, obviously, the Twins are doing something better than the Yankees, and the Yankees are throwing money around like they're at a strip club on Christmas.



Again, to the point about younger kids being a gamble. I get it. So, that means NONE of them are worth it? NO ONE is worth a risk? I simply don't agree. You don't need to pay every kid extra.
Sure, some day Terry Ryan might get a visit from one of the Pre-Cogs he calls scouts, who will insist that he has seen the future, and Jim Bob Joe Johnson is the next Ken Griffey, Jr., and then we will hope that Pohlad will let him open the purse a little for a signing bonus. I have no problem with the VERY occasional bonus over slot. I have a BIG problem with it becoming a regular thing. I also just don't trust your scouts like I trust ours.

(BTW, at least we're getting somewhere with the ownership profile. Yes, Pohlad is a billionaire...richer than Steinbrenner. After watching Steinbrenner for 25 years, I can tell you one thing for sure...that winning trumps everything else...even making money. Every fan would want an owner like that. EVERY FAN. The fact that Pohlad won't commit to winning first when he wouldn't miss the $$ isn't necessarily virtuous. Some could call it short-sighted and selfish. I mean, he didn't make billions by not taking any risks. Same principles here. He'd just rather not do it. Steinbrenner would.)
Yes. Carl Pohlad is evil. Find me a Minnesotan who disagrees and I'll buy you a pony.

Also, I don't feel that everyone should like the Yankees or that they're America's team or whatever. I don't believe they're better than the midwest because of geography. Like you Twins folk (or Brewers/White Sox folk), I was brought up believing the Yankees were the best because that's who my family rooted for. I have no problems with you hating the Yankees. I dislike other teams mostly because they're not the Yankees...regardless of where they're located.

Saturday, August 4, 2007

the 82 brewers are one of the best teams ever.

There is a brewer/national league post well overdue and it was going to be posted but then this following comment appeared:
"let's get down to brass tacks on the midwesterner's assumptions about the Yankees...that we simply purchase success. The very thought that we earned the latest dynasty through good decisions and a good farm system along with our money scares you all. That would mean we could beat other teams at their own game...through smart decisions and good player development. AND, we could back that up with deeper pockets. That combination would mean we'd be very tough to beat. So, as soon as someone in this argument admits this is a possibility...that the Yankees could do things by not just simply throwing their money around...the order of the universe would break down. Is this a fair assessment?"
WHAT????!!!!! (F'*!!@#^%*ing) NO! YOU'RE THE YANKEES!!!
There were other points made, and they are below. But the long day has been spent getting all of the arguments out there which requires one to read, edit and post all this intense dialogue while forming one's own opinions at the same time. And, well...to come across this I find myself frustrated, motivated and sad. Sad because really, some people just don't get it. And I feel that of all those people, Yankee fans dominate the group. Which makes me sad, because they are not dumb but they are nowhere near being right. Sad. As I said, I have to go and write (and drink, possibly heavily) but here are the "other points" as promised....

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Twins, I'll agree have produced better talent from their farm system over the past few years than the Yankees. So, their stats aren't surprising. Of course, these stats don't mean a whole lot. When the Yanks play the Twins in the regular season and the post season, they seem to pull the games out more often than not.

See again, the Twins and the Yankees have been able to get teams into the playoffs. The Yankees managed 6 pennants and 4 championships out their playoff teams. The Twins not so much with their recent teams. If a team makes the playoffs, is it fair to say they have the capability to win the WS? I'd say probably. Once you get to the playoffs the payroll and all of this $$ talk is largely irrelevant. The team is in position. The Yankees were able to put a special group of players together to win that went beyond simply spending $$. Again, I'll admit that's a part of our success yes. A necessary, but not sufficient condition for success. You still need other pieces to fall into place that money can't buy.

Again, to the point about younger kids being a gamble. I get it. So, that means NONE of them are worth it? NO ONE is worth a risk? I simply don't agree. You don't need to pay every kid extra.

(BTW, at least we're getting somewhere with the ownership profile. Yes, Pohlad is a billionaire...richer than Steinbrenner. After watching Steinbrenner for 25 years, I can tell you one thing for sure...that winning trumps everything else...even making money. Every fan would want an owner like that. EVERY FAN. The fact that Pohlad won't commit to winning first when he wouldn't miss the $$ isn't necessarily virtuous. Some could call it short-sighted and selfish. I mean, he didn't make billions by not taking any risks. Same principles here. He'd just rather not do it. Steinbrenner would.)

Also, I don't feel that everyone should like the Yankees or that they're America's team or whatever. I don't believe they're better than the midwest because of geography. Like you Twins folk (or Brewers/White Sox folk), I was brought up believing the Yankees were the best because that's who my family rooted for. I have no problems with you hating the Yankees. I dislike other teams mostly because they're not the Yankees...regardless of where they're located.

it's hard to be religious when certain people are never incinerated by bolts of lightning"

I heart Calvin and Hobbes. Bill Watterson gets to the core of serious issues and on top of providing ethics 101 he provides comedic relief to situations that could prove to be stressful and complex. Right now, I am looking for that humorous relief. Until then, my sanity has been preserved by Andy's comments below. The other participants, now that all are up to date, will be heard from soon. Ha!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. So the Meche contract has nothing to do with it? At all? C'mon. Then the Hendricks brothers are pretty bad agents. Also, remember that the Red Sox were in on the Clemens bidding. The Pavano signing was unfortunate. Though, lots of other teams were interested in a guy who went 18-8 the year before and had already pitched well in a WS.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pettitte's deal was finished the day after Meche's was. Unless the Yankees had Dayton Moore's office bugged, I'm pretty much positive they had nothing to do with each other. And since esteem for Boston's front office is pretty much equal to New York's, Boston's flirtation with Clemens comes over as profoundly uninteresting. Boring, creativity-deficient teams signing expensive veterans. Sun rises in east.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Correct, Clemens, Pettitte and Mussina are older. And? Somehow they're still getting guys out. It is unfortunate that Liriano is hurt, but after that, is anyone supposed to be impressed that after Santana the Twins are relying on Boof Bonser? Yeah, I'll take any of the 3 aforementioned veterans anyday for any length of time before that. Plus, having them on hand to mentor younger pitchers is bad why?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since the argument is furiously being argued that the Yankees are in the middle of some youth movement, I think that he should be impressed that a 96 win team in 2006 is counting on a 25 year old in their rotation. Unless it's just typical Yankee fan bluster? It's an odd dig either way, since Bonser has been better than both Clemens and Mussina this year, while costing a total of $400,000.

The reason I pointed to their ages in the first place was because Yankees fans congratulating themselves for the wisdom in not signing old men through the end of the decade. Making fewer dumb decisions isn't the same thing as being smart.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. We'll see about 2009, I suppose. It's certainly possible for the Yanks to trade some of them--maybe even for the likes of Johan Santana. But I highly doubt it will be for less. If that were the case, Gagne or Teixieria or both would be on the Yankees right now since all of these prospects were asked for. Maybe Kennedy is moving too fast. Maybe not. How many innings did any of the college pitchers that the A's have brought up recently pitch in the minors?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
I promise you that the Yankees don't have the goods in their system to trade for Santana. The only way he'll appear in pinstripes this decade is if they wait for him to finish 2008 without extending with Minnesota and then they back a truckload of money up to his house in Venezuela. Which actually should be a source of hope. If Yankees fans want Santana, they should hope that Cashman knows his strength: keeping his hand steady while he signs checks, not developing pitching prospects.

My only interest in Kennedy's promotions is in passing. If he ever gets big league hitters out, I don't expect it will be in New York anyhow. I actually don't know which Oakland pitchers he's talking about in particular. Braden's moved fast, but he was a 2004 pick and logged nearly 300 innings in the minor leagues. In any case, he's sort of a weird case because I don't think Oakland expects much of him. He was a 24th rounder who works with a novelty pitch. He's more part than prospect.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. Again, point taken that the draft is crap shoot...more busts than hits. I get it. That doesn't mean it's not worth spending money on players you feel are worth the risk. The Yanks don't over-slot every pick they make. Just because players are busts doesn't mean that others aren't worth the gamble. If someone had a great career, it'd certainly be worth it. If these guys are the nexus of a WS winning staff would it be worth it? Of course it would. If it were the Twins who did it and won, of course it would be worth it.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
But they're going about their pursuit of prospects the same way they went about their pursuit of free agents: letting the money cover the mistakes. They don't pay overslot to every pick because not every pick demands overslot money. It's not like there's some great level of discernment at work. Just cash. And then if the first batch of cash doesn't work, more cash.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. Wow, you're picking on Posada's role in 1996 to counter this point? Fair, I suppose, though he was the starter, and an all-star in 1999, 2000, and 2001. It was my fault for forgetting about Bernie. It wasn't intentional. He was a great Yankee. It was convenient for the Yankees to forget him? Huh? Because they didn't sign him to another 1 year deal? Really? They just tossed him aside? Sure. And Bernie was so pissed about this treatment he went and signed with who? Right. No one. Because he's a Yankee for life and he knows it. He doesn't want to play anywhere else. I highly doubt you'll find many people outside of Lofton and Sheffield that haven't loved playing in NY during the Torre era. And, who was he supposed to play ahead of based on last year's performance?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I picked on Posada because you were wrong about him. I wasn't countering anything, I just thought it was typically Orwellian Yankee fan behavior. Joe Girardi is unpersoned because he doesn't fit today's approved narrative. Maybe he'll rejoin the Yankees fold and be re-peopled, at which point his presence on the 1996 team will be remembered for his veteran leadership and invaluable mentoring to Jorge Posada. His family will be re-issued their treasured photo albums with his face reincluded and production will begin on his Yankeeography.

Berne Williams might not be so lucky. And they definitely tossed him aside. This is literally the first time I've ever seen anybody dispute this point. They failed to formulate a Bernie exit strategy of some sort and pretty clearly failed to articulate that they wanted him gone after 2006. He put up a 101 OPS+ this year, and the Yankees' bench hardly looks impressive enough that Bernie's 2006 line repeated wouldn't have been good enough. He outperformed what Johnny Damon's done this year and Miguel Cairo's been tapped to play 22 games at first base.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. I love the Maier mention. No dynasty without him. Except every Oriole fan conveniently forgets 3 things while crying in their beers: 1. Maier's catch only tied game 1; 2. The Orioles won game 2 and were in position to win the series without ever returning to NY; 3. The Orioles had a lead late in game 3 at home, blew the game, and lost 3 in a row at home. All because of Maier's catch! Oh, and by the way, the Yanks soundly spanked the Orioles during the year that year as well. I would agree that the Yanks dynasty ended after 2001. Sure their baseball decisions since then haven't been good...and, correct, no titles as a result.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is so incredibly not my fight. I don't care even a little bit about Jeffrey Maier. Except that it makes Yankees fans heated that they won a World Series in a year they that another team got jobbed. Somehow New York has become the wronged party here. Mean old baseball keeps bullying the Yankees. Ok. I lied. I appreciate the comedy value Maier provides. Good on that kid.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. So, the Yankees don't evaluate talent well since none of their picks were sleepers now? Oy. I'm sure they'll keep trying on this count. I would say that 'large disregard' for position players is a bit overstated with guys like Austin Jackson, Jose Tabata, and Jesus Montero in the fold. I love the Brad Halsey mention. Good one. I guess it's a good thing their international player development has produced Wang, Cano, and Cabrera...3 other guys that were supposedly over-hyped. Also, keep in mind the Yanks not only kept the right people in the late 90s...they also hyped and traded prospects that weren't as good. The Eric Miltons, Ruben Riveras, the Wily Mo Penas, the D'Angelo Jimenezs, the Ricky Ledees...in some cases the over-hyping was intentional.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If the shoe fits, right? If Joba Chamberlain had stayed at Nebraska-Kearney (we used to run against those guys once and awhile when I was in college) then I'd be impressed at the Yankees beating the bushes. But pre-season All-Americans are hardly the evidence of top notch detective work.

None of Jackson, Tabata or Montero has made the AA jump yet, so I think the very fact that I've heard of them is a pretty solid indication they're overhyped. There's only one team who's high-A and rookie-league prospects I care about, but for some reason guys like Tabata (who've literally never done anything but be young for their level) end up on my radar. Boston is actually worse at this. There was no reason for me to ever know who Abe Alvarez is, but there was a point where he was allegedly a hot commodity. I'm still fairly confident that Peter Gammons draws a paycheck from their front office for pumping up these guys.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. If they go after Zambrano, that's the end of the youth movement? So, they shouldn't look to sign a quality pitcher? You think they won't make room for Hughes next year because of Pavano and Igawa? Oy. Ok. Wishful thinking, but ok. I think the 5 best arms will start. All of the comparisons to Navarro, etc. are largely irrelevant. As Mark Shapiro's quote in the NY Times article from last month, along with the demands that were laid out at the trade deadline indicate, most general managers think these guys are the goods. So, let's wait and see. I'll say it again, if they wanted to deal them for Gagne or Teixiera they could have and would have. The major league club would certainly be better for it right now. You can't ignore that as an indication of their intentions, right?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't say it was the end of the youth movement. I said it would be a good clue. And I'm right. And I'm positive they'll make room for Hughes next year, even if it means DFAing the veterans and wasting the 13 million dollars or so they owe to Pavano and Igawa. That's kind of been my overriding point for this entire discussion: mistakes don't mean anything to New York because they've got the cash to cover it up. Throwing Hughes in the rotation is a necessity next year, and the smart thing to do. But the smartest thing would have been avoiding the issue and not signing bad veterans to contracts that outlived their usefulness so he had a place in the rotation waiting without the team having to flush a small fortune. If Yankees fans want to congratulate themselves for their brilliance in making the obvious and only logical choice, that's their right. As long as I don't have to humor them.

Hughes is the only prospect in the Yankees organization as valuable as Saltalamacchia. The price for Teixeira would have started with him, and adding Chamberlain wouldn't have equalled Atlanta's package. If they wanted Teixeira, they would have had to stand in line and participate in the auction like everybody else. And they would have come in second because they didn't have the system to compete with the Braves offer.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
9. So Cabrera has no potential? Ok. I mean, after tonight's action his average is above 290, his OBP is pushing 350 and he's got the potential to be a gold glove caliber defensive player with an outstanding arm. So, his stats as a major leaguer as a 21 and 22 year old should just be extrapolated? He won't improve as he goes along? Ok. Again, we'll see how he progresses. By this logic, Jeter after his rookie year would look impish as well. Good thing the Yanks stuck with him. All I know is that more than 1 GM asked for Cabrera at the deadline. I understand Damon is having a down year, but did you see his stats from last season? What was he, chopped liver out there? The career high in homers was just due to the short porch at the stadium? At the time he signed, Cabrera was 20-21. Signing Damon for 4 years when there would likely be another outfield spot open for Cabrera in the meantime wasn't a bad decision. Ok, Damon is having a bad year this year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't say Cabrera has no potential. I said he's not a "budding star". And I'm right. And your co-worker clearly agrees since he's scaled back that evaluation considerably already. I'm pretty comfortable saying he has potential. I'm comfortable compromising by saying Eric Byrnes is a nice comp. He'll have to stand in line for that Gold Glove, too, since THT has him at #7 in the AL. Safely in the middle of the pack. Though hope springs eternal, Derek Jeter never had to be the seventh best shortstop to win a suitcase full of Gold Gloves

Pre-meditated bulleting

Its funny how putting numbers or dots or roman numerals before ones thoughts basically have the same effect as a red flag in a bull fight...they draw you in and let you pounce in an expected, organized fashion. So we have another entry of bullets from a significant participant in this disussion...orchestrate your responses accordingly.

1. So the Meche contract has nothing to do with it? At all? C'mon. Then the Hendricks brothers are pretty bad agents. Also, remember that the Red Sox were in on the Clemens bidding. The Pavano signing was unfortunate. Though, lots of other teams were interested in a guy who went 18-8 the year before and had already pitched well in a WS.

2. Correct, Clemens, Pettitte and Mussina are older. And? Somehow they're still getting guys out. It is unfortunate that Liriano is hurt, but after that, is anyone supposed to be impressed that after Santana the Twins are relying on Boof Bonser? Yeah, I'll take any of the 3 aforementioned veterans anyday for any length of time before that. Plus, having them on hand to mentor younger pitchers is bad why?

3. We'll see about 2009, I suppose. It's certainly possible for the Yanks to trade some of them--maybe even for the likes of Johan Santana. But I highly doubt it will be for less. If that were the case, Gagne or Teixieria or both would be on the Yankees right now since all of these prospects were asked for. Maybe Kennedy is moving too fast. Maybe not. How many innings did any of the college pitchers that the A's have brought up recently pitch in the minors?

4. Again, point taken that the draft is crap shoot...more busts than hits. I get it. That doesn't mean it's not worth spending money on players you feel are worth the risk. The Yanks don't over-slot every pick they make. Just because players are busts doesn't mean that others aren't worth the gamble. If someone had a great career, it'd certainly be worth it. If these guys are the nexus of a WS winning staff would it be worth it? Of course it would. If it were the Twins who did it and won, of course it would be worth it.

5. Wow, you're picking on Posada's role in 1996 to counter this point? Fair, I suppose, though he was the starter, and an all-star in 1999, 2000, and 2001. It was my fault for forgetting about Bernie. It wasn't intentional. He was a great Yankee. It was convenient for the Yankees to forget him? Huh? Because they didn't sign him to another 1 year deal? Really? They just tossed him aside? Sure. And Bernie was so pissed about this treatment he went and signed with who? Right. No one. Because he's a Yankee for life and he knows it. He doesn't want to play anywhere else. I highly doubt you'll find many people outside of Lofton and Sheffield that haven't loved playing in NY during the Torre era. And, who was he supposed to play ahead of based on last year's performance?

6. I love the Maier mention. No dynasty without him. Except every Oriole fan conveniently forgets 3 things while crying in their beers: 1. Maier's catch only tied game 1; 2. The Orioles won game 2 and were in position to win the series without ever returning to NY; 3. The Orioles had a lead late in game 3 at home, blew the game, and lost 3 in a row at home. All because of Maier's catch! Oh, and by the way, the Yanks soundly spanked the Orioles during the year that year as well. I would agree that the Yanks dynasty ended after 2001. Sure their baseball decisions since then haven't been good...and, correct, no titles as a result.

7. So, the Yankees don't evaluate talent well since none of their picks were sleepers now? Oy. I'm sure they'll keep trying on this count. I would say that 'large disregard' for position players is a bit overstated with guys like Austin Jackson, Jose Tabata, and Jesus Montero in the fold. I love the Brad Halsey mention. Good one. I guess it's a good thing their international player development has produced Wang, Cano, and Cabrera...3 other guys that were supposedly over-hyped. Also, keep in mind the Yanks not only kept the right people in the late 90s...they also hyped and traded prospects that weren't as good. The Eric Miltons, Ruben Riveras, the Wily Mo Penas, the D'Angelo Jimenezs, the Ricky Ledees...in some cases the over-hyping was intentional.

8. If they go after Zambrano, that's the end of the youth movement? So, they shouldn't look to sign a quality pitcher? You think they won't make room for Hughes next year because of Pavano and Igawa? Oy. Ok. Wishful thinking, but ok. I think the 5 best arms will start. All of the comparisons to Navarro, etc. are largely irrelevant. As Mark Shapiro's quote in the NY Times article from last month, along with the demands that were laid out at the trade deadline indicate, most general managers think these guys are the goods. So, let's wait and see. I'll say it again, if they wanted to deal them for Gagne or Teixiera they could have and would have. The major league club would certainly be better for it right now. You can't ignore that as an indication of their intentions, right?

9. So Cabrera has no potential? Ok. I mean, after tonight's action his average is above 290, his OBP is pushing 350 and he's got the potential to be a gold glove caliber defensive player with an outstanding arm. So, his stats as a major leaguer as a 21 and 22 year old should just be extrapolated? He won't improve as he goes along? Ok. Again, we'll see how he progresses. By this logic, Jeter after his rookie year would look impish as well. Good thing the Yanks stuck with him. All I know is that more than 1 GM asked for Cabrera at the deadline. I understand Damon is having a down year, but did you see his stats from last season? What was he, chopped liver out there? The career high in homers was just due to the short porch at the stadium? At the time he signed, Cabrera was 20-21. Signing Damon for 4 years when there would likely be another outfield spot open for Cabrera in the meantime wasn't a bad decision. Ok, Damon is having a bad year this year.

Back to Virtue.

Virtue can be proven, it can even have excel spreadsheets to help understand it. They are available if need be.....

Following along the with the ongoing discussion:

While it is true that Carl Pohlad MORE than has the money to throw at the Twins if he chose to (he's a billionaire after all, and George Steinbrenner is just a lowly hundred-millionaire), I think the issue should not be how much out-of-pocket money the owner is willing to put toward the team. It should be how much they have, based on their revenues from ticket and fan product sales. That will HELP toward the understanding that the Twins and the Brewers really do work in a different world. So, let me make three inter-related points:

#1. The Twins work in a smaller market, with a population with less disposable income than the Yankees.
#2. Twins tickets and merchandise are cheaper than Yankees tickets and merchandise
#3. The Twins do more with the money that they have

#2 and #3 are incontrovertibly shown in the attached document. If he argues with #1 then you just have to give up on him because he's "touched." As you can see in my table, the Twins have an average ticket price more than $10 cheaper than the Yankees. This combined with a smaller market probably explains why their annual revenue is less than half of the Yankees'. In fact, they are at exact opposite ends of the rankings in revenue: the Yankees bring in the MOST and the Twins bring in the LEAST money of any major league team.

All that said, you can also see that in 2006 the Yankees had 97 wins and the Twins had 96. That puts the Twins at 27th in cost/win and the Yankees once again in first. So, obviously, the Twins are somehow able to muddle through with WAAAAAY less money. Now we're getting to the crux of the issue. The market in Minnesota and surrounding states is pretty well tapped. I don't see the kids out in Souix Falls and Brainerd shelling out for a cable channel (they tried it with hockey, and if Minnesota won't pay for hockey then they certainly won't pay for baseball), nor do I think you'll get away with big ticket price-raises in the new stadium (which, by the way, will seat about 10,000 fewer fans) or $100 Santana t-shirts. So, go ahead and come up with "creative" ways to make more money... all you're really saying is pass more of the cost on to the fans, and I'm saying that just won't fly in the thrifty Midwest. And it's not like we're selling a lot of caps overseas like the Yankees are.

So, we come back to the owners. I hold out hope that Pohlad will crack open that vault of his and throw a little money to us lonely beggars so that we can field a competitive team in the new stadium. However, I don't really think that's fair to him. Why should he have to pay for the mistakes of others? Because, really, I'm not mad at A-Rod. A-Rod is an all-star and I'd love to have him on my team. His salary is exorbitant, but it's not really like Jason Bartlett is going to go into contract negotiations with THAT salary in his mind. The problem is all the failures they've paid too much for. All the young kids who got those signing bonuses and never made it big. The slow and steady increase on players just out of serf-dom.

I was mad when it was big names, because it made me jealous. But really, the Twins were never in that market much. They weren't bumping up payroll by acquiring veterans from other teams, they were slowly losing their own veterans to the better deal elsewhere. That was always upsetting, but usually the Twins had someone in the background who was as good, or better, and would make the minimum (Mientkiewicz becomes Morneau, Pierzynksi become Mauer, Guardado becomes Nathan... the list goes on).

The scary thing to me is now the infiltration into those younger ages. If we can't compete for veterans, and so are destined to always be a young team, then we have to have faith that the people working in our AAA and AA and even A systems are the next Mauer. But if we can't afford the next Mauer either, because he gets a big signing bonus elsewhere, or because he knows we won't pour money all over him the first time he comes up for arbitration, then we are, as the pope would say, fucked.

And I don't blame Pohlad for not opening his purse under those conditions. "Penny wise and pound foolish" you say? Well, that may be true for some players, but when they are that young you can hardly KNOW that... if you have $200 million to throw around, you can afford to hand out signing bonuses to every kid you get that tingly feeling about, and you can give your feisty whelp with 3 years service time 5 million dollars in the hopes that he'll remain worth it. But when your market only brings in $2 million to the Yankees $4 million, you might not be able to just go on faith like that. And honestly, Midwestern values back in action, I don't think you SHOULD.

Oh, and just to throw it out there, the real reason I hate the Yankees is because they assume I love them. I hate New York and I hate LA because they think they're better than the Midwest and they expect us to agree. The Yankees are NOT "America's Team." The very thought sickens me.

i have an existential map; it has 'you are here' written all over it.

The discussion began before the blog was started. So to catch everyone up the remaining dialogue is all below. I wanted to do fancy things with the font to make it easier to follow but I have a Mac and am working on getting it formatted with this PC centric blogsite! No time for banter, let us get to the points at hand...

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3) In regards to the talent developed in the farm systems...keep in mind that when these guys reach the majors they get the major league minimum salary for probably the first 5 years of their career and they become arbitration-eligible. So, knowing that you're going to pay the kids chicken feed for a while, why not spend a bit more to ensure they sign with you after the draft? Penny-wise and pound-foolish if you ask me.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Players are in serfdom and are only obligated league-minimum salary for three years of service time, not five. It might seem like a small difference, but when the ideal is to have a player's least expensive years coincide with their early prime, an extra two years difference is pretty huge. Plus, arbitration payouts are hardly peanuts. Not everybody gets Soriano/Zambrano payouts of 10+mm dollars, but the fact that a salary can conceivably escalate to 30 times league minimum over a short three year period is something a lot of teams (you know, the ones that actually have budgets) need to plan for.

Again, I have a hard time arguing with the idea that turning prudence on its head actually IS prudence. Signing bonuses aren't pennies. And the reason not to overpay to ensure players sign with you is that a)then the demands will get out of control, like Andrew Miller's demands for an MLB appearance in 2006 to get his service-time clock started and b)not all of them will play MLB ball in their lifetime.

The only reason that teams have to pay out-of-slot bonus demands is that if they don't, another team will. And that's not a good enough reason, particularly when the draft is set up to give bad teams a shot to improve.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
(responding) Whether the arbitration comes at 3 years or 5 years, you’ve got to view an additional signing bonus (though I know it’s paid it out immediately) as being amortized over those years of relative serfdom for the good, young player. Yes, I know the salary increases through arbitration aren’t pennies (though, as you say, they aren’t like Soriano’s usually, either). But, if paying out a little more early gets you the good player, then you see what happens. If you don’t get the good player to start with, nothing will happen. Furthermore, I agree about the Andrew Miller situation, but that is, in part, an issue with agents as well. The classic example of this provision is the Todd Van Poppel fiasco. That clause, basically, ruined his career by forcing him to the majors before he knew how to pitch.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. Most owners operate teams solely to make money. Now, I understand that it's important to make money on your investment. That's fine. But, most owners refuse to understand that the best way to make money, in the LONG TERM, is to put a winning team on the field. Period. I remember when the Yankees were lucky to draw 2 million in a year. This year they'll draw 4 million. That's not because Yankee Stadium is in the best part of town, either. Steinbrenner's first goal has always been to win, which I've always appreciated. I do feel sorry for the Twins that Carl Pohlad spent probably 5 years convincing Selig to contract the team just so he could get a good deal on the team and be finished.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
He's right that winning has a huge impact on attendance, but it's been awhile since the main revenue stream for baseball teams was simply ticket sales. What allows the Yankees to be so profitable isn't winning. It's being one of two teams in a market that's been proven (when the Yanks, Dodgers and Giants were around) to be able to support at least three teams and can probably support four. The Yankees wont be making money because of Jeter's on-base percentage. It will be because of a deal on their new stadium that charges them ten dollars rent a year and their stake in the YES Network that's actually worth more than the entire team.
And all these things are fine, to be honest. It would be nice to be in their position. But hearing Yankees fans pretend they haven't lucked into a unique situation, that their success is the result of intelligence, gumption and pinstripe-y goodness is what bothers people. Like Lyndon Johnson said about RFK, "He was born on third base and thought he hit a triple".
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. Most owners cry poverty rather than being creative. So the Yankees start the YES network-nothing more than a regional sports network. Is this business model impossible to replicate in other markets? I would seriously doubt it."
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Carl Pohlad made his billions foreclosing on farms during the Depression. If completely overcoming any sense of human decency in order to make money isn't "creative" then nothing is. The Twins actually tried to start their own RSN, but it didn't work. They couldn't get enough money from local cable providers to make it profitable, so unless we've redefined "creative" as either "willing to operate at a loss in order to tell yourselves you've done everything the Yankees have done" or "keeping games on Victory Sports in order to hold fans hostage" then there was never a problem of creativity. It's not impossible to replicate in other markets. It's just really, really difficult to replicate profitably. And it having as much success with it as the Yankees enjoy probably is impossible.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. The Twins will be opening a new stadium in 2010. Not that I've researched it, but I'm assuming this stadium will be built largely on the generosity of the taxpayers. So, unencumbered by stadium costs, will the Twins make an investment in player salaries to put a good team on the field in 2010 to drive up attendance, merchandising, etc. and really take advantage of their new environment? Or will they continue to look to save $2M by trading all-star caliber players? At some point, I don't care if you're in MN or NY, you have to make an investment and spend money to ensure longer-term success.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
That's been the promise from the team so far, though obviously I'll believe it when I see it. It's worth noting that merchandising money is actually put into a pool and shared, though. A big part of the current problem is that the Twins don't control any of the luxury suites in the Metrodome, since the park was constructed for the Vikings and the Twins have been 3rd class tenants behind the Gophers and the Vikings for about two decades now. Jerry Bell says we'll see a larger payroll when the revenue can support it, and in the sense that charity believeth all things, I'm willing to accept the promise. Either way, it's silly to keep talking about the Twins since they actually are competitive.

On that note, I'm completely tired of the "they traded an All-Star 2B to save 2mm" meme from Twins' fans, so I'm definitely not interested in hearing it from Yankees fans. Castillo was a goner after the season anyhow. They've upgraded defensively and on the basepaths, and given the guy who was anointed as their 2008 second baseman a head start on learning on the job. It wasn't a salary dump, it was a lateral move in the present and a forward move for the future. Casilla will probably outplay Castillo over the stretch this year, and if he doesn't, Castillo isn't a valuable enough player to make the difference more than 1-2 wins.
----------------------------------------------------------
(responding) First, the Yankees are footing the bill for 90% of their new stadium. The only part the taxpayers are paying for, to my knowledge, are the public trans/parking improvements that are necessary. Secondly, as a fan since birth, and hearing more than my share about the good old days for the Yanks, I can basically say that when the Yankees made good baseball decisions, they’ve won. When they haven’t then they haven’t won. When CBS owned the team in the late 60s and into the 70s they were awful. No investment in anything. In the 70s, Gabe Paul built that team brilliantly. After the early 80s when Paul was gone and Steinbrenner stopped developing talent and attempted to make up for it with free agents, the team suffered. Finally, Steinbrenner was banished in the early 90s and Gene Michael built-up the farm system again, the Yankees took off. Again, no one will ever convince me the Yankees would’ve won championships without Jeter, Williams, Pettitte, Rivera, and Posada. On top of that, we TRADED for Tino Martinez and Paul O’Neill. Teams actually gave these players to us. Again, are these players the result of us having more money or good baseball decisions? I understand that keeping them all together takes money. But assembling them? That is intelligence and gumption.

Going further on the finances…Correct, the Yankees’ share of YES is worth roughly $4B and the team itself is worth $1.5B. But, how is it possible that the $1.5B is in no way connected to attendance. A revenue stream driven by attendance will have a significant impact on the teams’ overall valuation (as will their owning 90% of their new stadium). If this isn’t the case, why would teams build new stadiums to attract more people? Why would the Twins take the chance of building a new stadium if people aren’t going to come out in higher numbers?

I agree that simply throwing money at problems isn’t praiseworthy. Using money to back-up smart baseball decisions is, however. That epitomizes the Yankees of the late 90s and, hopefully, the Phil Hughes Yankees to come.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. I've said it before and I'll say it again, the fact the Yankees are richer than everyone else isn't new. It's been that way for 100 years. The Yankees still haven't won every year. So, other teams must have some way of competing with them.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, the way to compete with the Yankees is to be smarter and more resourceful. These things are actual virtues that teams like Oakland and Cleveland and Minnesota possess. And I'm fine simply watching my team compete with the Yankees on the field with these conditions. I actually don't have any real problem with the Yankees themselves so long as they're unapologetic about what they do. The irritation comes with Yankees fans insisting on turning common sense on its head and insisting that outspending the field and throwing more piles of cash at any problem is something virtuous and praiseworthy. It isn't. It just makes it more impressive when smarter, better teams beat New York and Boston at their own rigged game.

Strangle and Hug.

So the aforementioned 7-point response has caused quite the conversation. (the points are included) Its one of those conversations where in the core of your "being" you know the other person must just be misguided and that when it comes down to it they just don't know. The issue is that "they" are making sense, and have valid points but in the end they are just wrong. These conversations are what keep people up at night strategizing on how to enlighten the other, thinking about how to finally convince them. It's an intelligent, quick discussion...so I hope everyone can keep up!

1. The Yankees are not solely responsible for running-up prices and causing this overall 'lack of loyalty.' I mean free agency has been in effect for over 30 years and lots of teams have thrown money around. Who gave ARod $250M? Who signed Gil Meche (Gil Meche!!) for $11M/year? Not the Yankees. Who gave Barry Zito $126M? Not the Yankees.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Is this where the line to congratulate the Yankees for not offering the two worst contracts of this last off-season starts? Or did the movement disband when they gave Roger Clemens 17.4mm for 20 starts of almost exactly league-average pitching?

Obviously the Yankees aren't the only team with horrendous spending habits, and along with the Red Sox I'm happy to give them a gold star for actually doing it and winning once and awhile, unlike some fairly recent incarnations of the Mets and Cubs and Rangers. That said, the Yankees aren't just at the head of the class when it comes to this irresponsibility. They own the classroom and the school. It's rather telling that your friend couldn't pick three enormous contracts without including one that naturally found its way to the Bronx. New York is the place where horrific, burdensome contracts go to die: Rodriguez, Abreu, Randy Johnson, Kevin Brown.

The problem isn't that the Yankees make players disloyal, or even that they spend more than other teams. It's that the spend so much more than other teams that their mistakes are completely irrelevant budget-wise. Any remotely responsible team would have been crippled by giving Carl Pavano 39.95mm over 4 years with a return of 111 innings over the first THREE seasons of the contract. The Yankees response to what would be a huge millstone around any budgetary neck has been... atypical: finding more expensive, less insurable pitchers to fill the gap, like Andy Pettitte and Roger Clemens.

A less dramatic example is the recent weirdness with Johnny Damon. After winning the bidding for the player Scott Boras billed as "better than Rickey Henderson" with a comparatively modest and non-escalating 4y/52mm, they discovered just a year and a half into the deal that he can't really play centerfield that well anymore and is kind of falling apart. But what would have been a disaster for most other teams turned into a stroke of luck for the Yankees: Jason Giambi, who is owed 42mm (yeah, you read that right) over '07-'08 with a 22mm club option for 2009 (the Yankees have a 5mm buyout on this) can't stay healthy or field a position either. So, Damon and his 93 OPS+ is available to take over the "position" of DH that Giambi isn't often physically capable of filling. So the Yankees are paying a total of 34 million dollars to fill their DH need at below league-average offense.

Spending money for elite talent doesn't bother me. Guys like Jeter, Rodriguez, etc. are generational talents who should be retained at almost any cost for a winning team. Choosing to spend money on players like this would be bold and aggressive, and I don't believe the contracts for HOF-calibre players really has any great effect on the market. Aramis Ramirez had a comparable 2006 to Alex Rodriguez, but it didn't get him ARod money when he opted out of his current contract. The problem, however, is that the Yankees don't stop at bold and aggressive. They spend their money like a bludgeon, raising the rates on production that is either mediocre (Damon) or uncertain (Pavano). Pointing out that other owners are billionaires and theoretically can keep up with the Yankees misses the point: that they shouldn't keep up with the Yankees.
---------------------------------------------------
(in response) My larger point on the worst of the off-season contracts is completely missed. If the Royals pay Gil Meche, an average pitcher at best, $11M per year then how much will a pitcher with nearly 200 victories (and, I might add, a product of the Yankee farm system) Andy Pettitte going to demand? Or a hall of famer like Clemens? So, because the Yankees look to fill holds on the staff with reliable arms for the year, they need to overpay because the Royals are a moronic franchise. That leads to the overall larger expense
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. The Yankees have paid the other 29 teams $100M in luxury tax and revenue sharing money. That's over $3M on average, per team. So, they pay for their excesses more than any other franchise on the planet. What do most owners do with this money? Pocket it. Can anyone make a serious argument that owners couldn't afford to take this money and pay a draft pick an extra $500K not to go to college? Seriously?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is an even stranger attempt to reframe the conversation in order to make the Yankees' behavior look prudent, since New York only somewhat recently decided that their consistent waste of money should also be applied to the amateur draft and international scouting. I refuse to argue along the lines that wasting money should be standard, preferable practice. A half-million dollars for an 18 year old player with no real certainty of even making an MLB roster is a ton of money. Refusing to pay above slot isn't cheap, it's smart.

It's also not entirely correct to suggest that the Yankees are throwing money at HS draftees. Dellin Betances was their only prep pick in the first 10 rounds of the 2006 draft. With the exception of Betances and Hughes, most of their prep picks in the last few years have sort of languished. CJ Henry has been the most useful prep 1st rounder (until Hughes gets his feet set at the MLB level) since he managed to net Abreu - a return that, as far as I can discern was appealing simply so Gillick could tell people Henry was a 1st rounder. They went with a few prep position players in the 2007 draft, but the pick that most defined this recent draft and their draft strategy of late was Andrew Brackman at #30. Brackman will end up being signed for above-slot money, in spite of regressing in K/9 for his junior year and having basically no leverage due to injury problems. All because he's really tall.

This isn't an example MLB teams need to be following.

Besides, the "pocketing the luxury tax" argument only really applies to a couple teams, like the Pirates and the Royals. I don't have much trouble lumping them in with the Yankees as far as "things that are wrong with baseball's financial structure". I'm perfectly comfortable disliking both ends of the spectrum equally.
-------------------------------------------------
(in response) Also, keep in mind the Yankees’ longer term strategy with the pitching staff. The contracts signed by Pettitte, Mussina, and Clemens are all short term…1 or 2 years. By 2009 the rotation will largely be made-up of prospects developed within the organization. Which leads to my next point…

Overpaying at draft slots is not sound? The Yankees do it not only for prep players like Betances. Look at the players every team has asked the Yankees for this year in trade deals: Ian Kennedy, Joba Chamberlain, and Alan Horne. All college players drafted in the last few years…all top shelf prospects that are projected to have good major league careers. Because they’re not quite up to the Bronx yet doesn’t make them bad investments. And, by the way, why was Kennedy available where the Yankees picked, late in the first round? Injury concerns during his last season at USC. So, the point about Brackman is valid, he certainly may end up being a reach. But, for a guy that throws that hard is it not worth a risk at pick 30? I mean if the Yankees had the top pick this is a different conversation. Not taking into account their draft status when making that point causes you to miss the point. The Yankees are strategic in how they go about making-up for their lack of draft position each year.

This all gets me to my point in noting the Yankees are richer than everyone else is not born of arrogance. I’m trying to make the point that good baseball decisions end up leading to championships, period…rich teams or poor teams. I don’t buy the argument that the Yankees have good pitching prospects simply because they’re rich. They have good pitching prospects because they make good decisions on who to draft and where to draft them. Same thing with their latest dynasty. Built from free agency? Partly. However, does anyone think the Yankees would have won any of those titles with Pettitte, Rivera, Jeter, or Posada? I don’t. The Yankees built a solid core of players and used the rest of their prospects to land the other pieces of the puzzle.

The next argument that usually gets thrown around is that the Yankees spend more on scouting than other teams. Likely yes overall. But by how much? How many teams scouted and could have drafted Hughes, Kennedy, or Chamberlain…lots. If other teams are dedicated to ‘building from within’ then shouldn’t their scouting department be getting the bulk of the investment dollars (as Stan Kasten has recently done with Washington, building off the model he used in Atlanta)? At some point the fact that the owners have resources to spend IS valid. They don’t want to spend on salaries like the Yankees? Fine. Where IS the money going? Teams that don’t spend money on their major league roster (I think that extends beyond Pitts. And KC) are also largely guilty of not investing in player development.

The points about the Damon and Giambi contracts are certainly valid. I would add that part of Johnny’s lack of playing time in center is also because the Yankees have a budding, 23 year old star in CF in Melky Cabrera that was developed through the farm system.

To the last point about overpaying 18 year olds. I agree that the draft is a gamble. But saying that it’s not smart to overpay because a player may not make it, to a degree, misses the point. That’s the nature of all drafts in all sports. At some point, you NEED to take chances on players. Can someone say for sure that when the Twins signed Rod Carew as an 18 year old he’d be a hall of famer? I’m sure not, but he was signed anyway.